How to Win Difficult Clients (Insurance)

In the insurance business, difficult clients are part of the territory. Some are skeptical of policies, others are unhappy about premiums, and a few simply do not trust the industry. But if you can win them over, these clients often become your most loyal advocates — and they tend to refer others in their network.

1. Identify Their Core Concerns

Difficult clients usually have a reason for being cautious. Maybe they had a bad claim experience, paid for coverage they never used, or felt misled in the past. Ask open-ended questions and listen without interrupting. The more they share, the more you understand how to approach them.

2. Simplify the Complex

Insurance is complicated. The jargon, clauses, and fine print can overwhelm clients. Break down policy terms into plain language. For example, instead of saying “comprehensive auto coverage,” explain that it protects their car from theft, vandalism, and certain weather damage.

3. Show the Real-World Value

Clients become more trusting when they see practical benefits. Share real claims stories — anonymized for privacy — that illustrate how coverage protected someone from significant financial loss. If you sell travel insurance, give examples of how it saved clients from paying thousands in emergency medical bills abroad.

4. Be Transparent About Costs

Pricing skepticism is common in insurance. Provide a clear breakdown of what each premium covers, what is excluded, and why. If a cheaper competitor exists, explain the trade-offs so the client understands the value in your offer.

5. Offer Flexible Options

Instead of pushing one plan, present multiple coverage options at different price points. This puts the client in control, which often reduces resistance.

6. Follow Through Promptly

Difficult clients test your reliability. Return calls quickly, send requested documents without delay, and confirm all promises in writing. Consistency builds confidence.

7. Stay Professional During Pushback

Some clients will question every detail or challenge your recommendations. Respond with facts, remain calm, and keep the focus on how your policy protects them.

8. Maintain the Relationship After the Sale

Winning a difficult client does not end when they sign the policy. Check in periodically to ensure they are happy with their coverage, and be proactive about reviewing and adjusting their plan as life circumstances change.

Final Thoughts

In insurance, difficult clients are not obstacles — they are opportunities. By listening, simplifying, proving value, and following through, you can turn skeptics into long-term policyholders who trust you with their most important assets.

Get in touch, we're here to help.